Graeagle Mill Works: The Story Behind Our Famous Potato Salad
Last week we explored different types of comfort food and I asked you to share your favorites and memories. If you missed it, catch up here. This week, let’s dive into the recipe that stole the show at the annual golfers’ picnic: Graeagle Mill Works’ famous potato salad.
What Comfort Food Means to Me
Comfort food shifts with the seasons and settings. On a crisp winter evening, nothing warms me like a hearty homemade soup. Come summer, an ice-cold potato salad at a backyard BBQ is pure bliss.
Imagine sitting on a wildflower-strewn meadow at sunset, sweet tea in hand, juicy watermelon on your plate, and that creamy potato salad front and center. That scene captures why this recipe feels like home.
A Recipe Rooted in Family Tradition
Both of my grandmothers were master cooks, each with their own potato salad version. Over time I blended their techniques into one hybrid recipe that became a Graeagle Mill Works legend and a best-seller at the Graeagle Store.
Through early mornings of peeling and dicing 20 pounds of potatoes, I watched my grandma’s arthritic fingers expertly guide new helpers. Those memories—her gentle corrections, her laughter—infused every batch with love.
Why Technique Matters More Than Ingredients
I believe a great potato salad isn’t just about what you use but how you put it together. Precise cooking, cooling, cutting, and mixing turn simple ingredients into something unforgettable.
Are you team sweet pickles or dill? Olives, bacon, or jalapeños? Mayonnaise or a tangy vinaigrette? Your choices matter, but mastering the process is essential.
Top Tips for Perfect Potato Salad
- Choose uniform, medium-sized red potatoes for an ideal balance of waxiness and creaminess.
- Start potatoes in heavily salted cold water and boil uncovered until fork-tender.
- Shock them under cold running water immediately—no soggy blobs or runny salad.
- Hand-cut each potato into flakes of varied sizes for texture and creaminess.
- Mix vigorously with gloved hands, pressing and folding until every morsel is coated.
Share Your Potato Salad Story
Do you have a cherished potato salad memory from a family gathering? Share it in the comments below—I’d love to read about your star-role moments. here.
Join Our Free Community
Want the inside scoop on Graeagle Mill Works recipes? Subscribe to our free membership for exclusive content, early cookbook access, and a vibrant community of food lovers. It’s completely free and we never share your information. Join here.
What’s Next?
In an upcoming post, I’ll reveal our secret Raspberry Vinaigrette dressing and share the perfect pulled-pork companion for this potato salad. Stay tuned!
Log in to view the recipe:
Subscribe to continue reading
Subscribe to get access to the rest of this post and other subscriber-only content.
One response to “Graeagle Mill Works: Potato Salad”