The Family Scapegoat: A Journey from Childhood Jealousy to Adult Betrayal
My Personal Anecdote
I grew up the youngest step-child in a blended household where jealousy and triangulation were the unspoken rules of engagement. My step-siblings, fueled by resentment over shared parental attention, often blamed me for minor mishaps—spilled milk, misplaced keys, anything that went wrong became “my fault.” At family gatherings, my sister-in-law echoed their jibes, stamping me as the perennial troublemaker, a pattern that persisted even after I married and had children of my own. My ex-husband and then my own kids, echoing generational blame, began to scapegoat me under the guise of discipline. I realized that the label of “scapegoat” had become my identity, stretching from my step-siblings’ cruelty in childhood to my children’s misplaced anger in adulthood.
Rediscovering My Truth
It wasn’t until therapy that I recognized how this false narrative had overridden my sense of self. I learned that scapegoating often arises unconsciously within dysfunctional family systems, where one individual carries the burden of the group’s dysfunction to maintain a fragile balance. Understanding that I was never the true source of all that went wrong freed me to question the blame and begin trusting my own experience again.
The Psychology Behind Scapegoating
Family Systems and Projection
Scapegoating fits squarely within Family Systems Theory, which posits that families unconsciously assign roles—hero, lost child, scapegoat—to manage stress and conflict. When anxiety rises between two members, a third is drawn in to stabilize the tension, a process known as triangulation. This triangle can be seen in my childhood home: step-siblings and in-laws united against me to avoid confronting their own insecurities.
Relational Gaslighting
Gaslighting is a manipulation technique that distorts a victim’s reality, leading them to doubt their own perceptions and memories. In families, gaslighting can take the form of outright denials—“That never happened”—or subtler undermining tactics like calling a child “too dramatic” or “oversensitive” when they protest unfair blame. I remember being told my memories were false, which made me fear I was “crazy” for holding onto the truth.
The Emotional Toll of Being the Scapegoat
Identity Confusion and Self-Esteem
When you’re the family’s designated scapegoat, identity confusion is common. Constant blame leads to low self-esteem and feelings of worthlessness. Research shows that youth forced into this role are more likely to experience abuse, neglect, and long-term psychological distress, including depressive symptoms in adulthood.
Chronic Stress and Trauma
Being scapegoated floods the nervous system with chronic stress. Many scapegoats develop complex post-traumatic stress symptoms (C-PTSD), carrying the emotional burdens into adulthood and experiencing triggers that feel disproportionate to the present threat. Trauma-informed experts warn that re-exposing victims to these wounds without proper care can worsen outcomes, highlighting the need for specialized approaches to healing.
Betrayal Trauma
Betrayal by family members can cut deeper than any external wound. When the people who are meant to protect you become your tormentors, the resulting trauma—Betrayal Trauma—undermines your ability to trust, both in others and in yourself. This form of trauma often requires targeted therapeutic strategies to rebuild trust and personal safety.
Coping and Healing Strategies
Trusting Yourself and Building Self-Compassion
Step one in recovery is reclaiming self-trust. Daily affirmations and self-compassion exercises counteract the internalized messages of blame. As one expert notes, learning to talk to yourself as you would a close friend is essential for survivors of family scapegoating.
Setting Boundaries and Reclaiming Power
Learning to say “no” is vital when your body tenses at the thought of yet another unjust accusation. Clear, consistent boundaries—communicated calmly and enforced firmly—signal that you will no longer tolerate emotional abuse. In group settings, this practice aligns with trauma-informed care principles aimed at creating physical and emotional safety.
Trauma-Informed Therapies
Trauma-informed stabilization treatment models such as Dr. Janina Fisher’s TIST integrate structural dissociation theory, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, and sensorimotor psychotherapy to help survivors process implicit memory held in the body, without re-traumatizing them with repeated recounting of the abuse. Seeking out a TIST-trained therapist or other trauma-informed practitioners can provide a safe path to integration and wholeness.
Narrative and Strength-Based Approaches
Re-authoring your story through narrative therapy empowers you to see the scapegoating role as separate from your identity. Strength-based interventions, such as identifying personal talents and values, foster resilience and build new neural pathways for positive self-perception. Techniques like journaling, expressive writing, or the “peak experience” exercise help highlight moments when you were at your best, reminding you of your innate capabilities.
Building a Supportive Community
Connecting with others who understand family scapegoating—through peer support or online communities—reduces isolation and normalizes your experiences. Shared narratives validate your truth and offer practical insights for moving forward. Research shows that community storytelling and mutual support significantly improve emotional health outcomes.
Healing from family scapegoating is not a quick fix; it’s a journey of rebuilding trust, rewriting your narrative, and reclaiming your power. Yet by integrating family systems insight, addressing gaslighting and betrayal trauma, and embracing trauma-informed and strength-based therapies, you can emerge stronger and more self-assured than ever before. Remember, your story matters—share it, honor it, and let it guide you to a life defined by authenticity and compassion, rather than the wounds of the past.
References
8
- 1www.centerpsychologygroup.comThe family scapegoat: A symptom of dysfunction
- 2www.psychologytoday.comThe Role of Triangles in Family Dynamics | Psychology Today
- 3tacklingreligiousnarcissism.comStrategies for Surviving As a Scapegoat Spouse of a Narcissist
- 4www.psychologytoday.com5 Ways to Heal from Being the Family Scapegoat – Psychology Today
Example of a Trauma Informed Organizational Framework Policy
How to Heal from Family Scapegoating Abuse (FSA)
What is a Strength-Based Approach? (Incl. Examples & Tools)
Storytelling in Mental Health: Techniques for Professionals
Leave a comment